Pre-Implantation Selection Today

I tend to talk about pre-implantation and artificial selection as something in the future. It mostly is, especially in terms of hybridization, but not entirely. It is already starting to occur.
The first goal of artificial selection is the removal of "bad" genes. Bad genes are genes that do not work properly due to changes in their structure caused by mutation or recombination. Sometimes bad genes are natural genes that just cause problems for a variety of reasons.
Sickle cell anemia is an example of a gene that is advantageous in some cases, but there is a very bad trade off in others. It can protect the carrier from malaria, but it can also kill the carrier.
There are other traits that don't cause problems when a person is younger, but they can fail or may be prone to cancer as the person gets older.

In a sense, selection against bad genes is an example of the second case of eugenics, selection for "good" genes, simply because selection against a known bad gene is selection for an unknown good gene. In general, evolution does not create bad genes. It does create genes that are better though and genes that are compromises.

In any case, though much of the potential of artificial selection is in the future, some of the knowledge and much of the basic techniques required for it already exists and is already being used.
In one case, it was used to prevent the inheritance of a form of early onset Alzheimers disease. In another slightly different case, it was used to insure that one child would be a compatible donor for an older child.
In both cases, there are other moral issues raised. In the first, it was assumed that the mother would not be capable of raising the children to maturity, because her "bad' gene was going to leave her mentally incapacitated. In the second case,

Back To Home Page